The Accidental Picasso Thief: The True Story of a Reverse Heist, Outrunning the FBI, and Fleeing the Boston Mob

The Accidental Picasso Thief: The True Story of a Reverse Heist, Outrunning the FBI, and Fleeing the Boston Mob book cover

The Accidental Picasso Thief: The True Story of a Reverse Heist, Outrunning the FBI, and Fleeing the Boston Mob

Author(s): Whit Rummel (Author), Noah Charney (Author)

  • Publisher: Bloomsbury Academic
  • Publication Date: November 27, 2025
  • Language: English
  • Print length: 168 pages
  • ISBN-10: B0F93B5PN3
  • ISBN-13: 9798765188262

Book Description

In early 1969, a wooden crate containing a valuable Picasso painting titled 'Portrait of a Woman and a Musketeer' vanished from Logan Airport in Boston during a snowstorm. It was being shipped from Paris, France, to a gallery in Milwaukee, but ended up in the hands of Merrill "Bill" Rummel, a young forklift operator who worked at Emery Airfreight. He took it home and discovered the package contained the painting. Not particularly appreciating the art, he decided to hide it in his closet. Weeks later, the FBI began to investigate, and Bill and his fiancée panicked. They panicked further when they learned that the Winter Hill Mob, the Boston gang run by Whitey Bulger, had learned of the theft and was on the hunt for it too. How could this accidental Picasso thief possibly escape the mob and the FBI?
Bill's younger brother, Whit, Jr., suggested he call his father.  Miraculously, Whitcomb Rummel Sr., a well-known, respected businessman in Waterville, Maine, devised a daring and risky scheme to safely return the painting without revealing who'd taken it. The bit of skullduggery succeeded without a hitch, and the Rummel trio pulled off the one-of-a-kind "reverse heist" without ever being identified.
But that's not the end of this story. Soon after its return in 1969, the Picasso mysteriously disappeared again. No sign of its whereabouts could be found. Finally, fifty years later, young Whit, the sole remaining member of the original gang, hired a private investigator to trace what had happened to it. He eventually discovered it had been part of a 1970 exhibition in Milwaukee. The owners were listed as Sidney and Dorothy Kohl of Kohl's Department store fame. Could this possibly be where the painting had ended up?  
The Accidental Picasso Thief, authored by Whit Rummel Jr. and art crime expert Noah Charney, tells the complete story in all its unexpected and wonderful details.

Editorial Reviews

Review

“Narrated in rollicking fashion.” ―Booklist

From the Author

Whit Rummel grew up in Waterville, Maine, where his father, Whit Sr., was a respected businessman who shaped his childhood in extraordinary ways. After graduating from Tulane University in New Orleans in 1969, Whit had several occupations before embarking on a career in communications and screenwriting.
In 1969, his family became entangled in one of the strangest episodes in American art crime: the disappearance of a Picasso painting from Logan Airport in Boston. That story, combined with his own memories of Waterville, Boston, and 1969, a turbulent year in American history, became the foundation of his first book,
The Accidental Picasso Thief (2025).
Now living in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, Whit continues to write and reflect on the ways art, crime, and family history intersect. At 78, he believes stories are meant to be
shared, not hidden away—just like great works of art.

View on Amazon